Belize’s English: Exploring Colonial Roots and Modern Identity

Belize’s English: Exploring Colonial Roots and Modern Identity

Belize is renowned for its exceptional linguistic heritage, proudly recognized as the sole English-speaking nation in Central America. This remarkable distinction is rooted in its vibrant history and British colonial influence, which have significantly shaped both the cultural and linguistic identity of the country over centuries. As you immerse yourself in Belize’s historical journey, you will discover the vital contributions of British settlers, known as Baymen, who established their foothold in the region during the 17th and 18th centuries. Their influence was profound, leading to a dramatic shift in the local culture and language. The designation of British Honduras solidified English as the official language, reinforcing a unique linguistic identity that clearly distinguishes Belize from its Spanish-speaking neighbors.

Discover the Historical Roots Behind Belize’s Unique Language Identity

The evolution of language in Belize can be traced back to its complex colonial past, rich with various influences. The identity of Belize as an English-speaking country is the result of a distinctive blend of British colonialism, interactions with local indigenous communities, and the dynamics of maritime trade. By exploring the timeline of Belize’s history, you will gain insights into how British intervention significantly influenced the cultural and linguistic development of the country, transforming what was once a territorial region into a nation characterized by its unique identity and cultural richness within the region.

Understand the Transformative Impact of the British Colonial Period

Starting in the early 17th century, British settlers began to radically alter the linguistic environment in Belize. You’ll observe how British logwood traders and settlers progressively adopted English as the primary language for governance and commerce. Their economic activities, particularly in timber extraction and later in agriculture, integrated English into daily communication practices, fundamentally reshaping Belize’s linguistic trajectory. This transformation laid the foundation for English to thrive in the area, establishing it as a cornerstone of national identity and societal cohesion.

Trace Significant Milestones in Belize’s Journey Toward Sovereignty

The pathway leading Belize to independence showcases a series of significant events, reflecting pivotal decades that transitioned from British colonial dominance to achieving independence in 1981. Key milestones include progressive constitutional reforms and the self-governance period that commenced in 1964, leading to negotiations for independence. These developments ensured that English retained its status as the official language, fortifying its integral role in the nation’s identity and governance framework.

Gain Perspective on Independence and Its Far-Reaching Effects

Examining Belize’s path to independence reveals a complex political evolution. You will gain a deeper understanding of how peaceful negotiations with the United Kingdom facilitated a seamless transition to self-governance. During this critical period, Belize maintained strong linguistic and administrative ties to British systems, which fundamentally influenced the ongoing use of English. This historical context highlights how Belize effectively leveraged its colonial heritage to cultivate a distinct national identity while progressing toward independence, making English a vital element of its sociopolitical framework.

Delve into the Influence of English in Colonial Education Systems

As you investigate the linguistic structure of Belize, you will discover that British colonial educational policies played a pivotal role in shaping the language dynamics of the nation. The British established English as the primary language of instruction, crafting a strategic educational framework that permanently altered the cultural communication landscape. This system ensured that English became the dominant medium of education, effectively transforming the learning environment for countless generations of Belizeans and embedding the language deeply within the national identity.

Examine the Development of Educational Institutions During British Rule

In Belize, educational institutions were established under direct British colonial oversight, with missionary schools playing a critical role in conveying language and cultural values. These early educational establishments served not only as venues for academic learning but were also strategically designed to promote English linguistic norms. The British intentionally set up schools prioritizing English instruction, cultivating an organized educational environment that gradually reduced the prominence of indigenous languages while reinforcing English as a crucial skill for social and economic advancement.

Evaluate the Growth of Literacy Rates and Language Proficiency

Throughout your exploration, you will note that English literacy rates in Belize saw significant increases during the colonial era. By the mid-20th century, approximately 75% of the population had acquired functional proficiency in English, showcasing the efficacy of the comprehensive educational initiatives introduced by British authorities. This evolution was more than an academic milestone; it represented a major cultural transformation, reshaping the identity of Belizean society and embedding English into the daily lives of its citizens.

Acquiring English language skills became a crucial mechanism for social mobility and economic advancement. You will realize that language acquisition transcended mere educational objectives; it became a pathway to enhanced opportunities. The British colonial framework effectively linked English proficiency to professional success, motivating Belizeans to learn the language. Mastery of English opened doors to improved job prospects, administrative roles, and elevated social standings, thus making language an indispensable tool for cultural and economic integration within Belizean society.

Examine the Distinctions Between the Official Language and Local Dialects

As you delve deeper into Belize’s linguistic landscape, you will uncover a complex and multifaceted dynamic. While English is recognized as the official language, the nation’s communication is further enriched by a diverse array of cultural influences. You’ll discover that, despite its colonial origins, the linguistic situation in Belize is not simply binary; rather, it is a vibrant interplay of historical and social forces that shape communication across various communities, reflecting the rich cultural heritage of the country.

Understand the Importance of English in Belizean Society

In addition to its official status, English functions as the primary language for government, education, and media. Notably, around 63% of the population uses English as either their first or second language, underscoring its deep-rooted significance in Belizean society. This linguistic dominance stems directly from the nation’s British colonial past and continues to play a crucial role in defining national identity while promoting social cohesion among the diverse ethnic groups that inhabit Belize.

Explore the Emergence and Significance of Belizean Creole

Local Belizean Creole, often referred to as Kriol, stands out as a dynamic linguistic hybrid, featuring a rich blend of English vocabulary and African grammatical structures. Approximately 37% of the population speaks this language, which serves as a profound expression of cultural resilience and identity, transcending the limitations imposed by colonial linguistic frameworks. This evolving language has become an essential aspect of Belizean identity, representing a fusion of historical experiences and contemporary realities.

Legal documentation and linguistic research indicate that Belizean Creole originated during the period of slavery, evolving as a means of communication among enslaved Africans with diverse linguistic backgrounds. You will appreciate how this language has transformed into a symbol of cultural survival and resistance, evolving from a basic survival tool into a proud emblem of Belizean heritage, reflecting the struggles and victories of its speakers throughout history.

Investigate the Variety of Minority Languages in Belize

On the periphery of the linguistic spectrum, you will uncover Belize’s remarkable array of languages. Maya languages like Q’eqchi’ and Mopan, alongside Spanish and Garifuna, coexist within this multilingual environment, representing about 25% of the population’s linguistic diversity. This rich variety echoes Belize’s intricate historical and cultural interactions, providing a glimpse into the lived experiences of its many communities.

The linguistic diversity in Belize is not merely a communicative tool; it serves as a testament to cultural preservation. You will find that speakers of minority languages actively work to maintain their linguistic heritage through community education, cultural festivities, and the transmission of knowledge across generations. These languages serve not only as means of communication but also as living archives of historical and cultural wisdom, essential to the identity of their speakers.

Analyze the Modern Implications of Language Diversity in Belize

Belize’s linguistic heritage reflects its multifaceted colonial history and shapes contemporary social and economic dynamics. You will discover that the multilingual landscape presents unique opportunities and challenges, with English acting as a unifying medium while simultaneously preserving the nation’s rich cultural diversity. This complex linguistic framework enables Belizeans to engage in global interactions while honoring their distinct national identity, fostering a sense of pride and belonging.

Assess the Role of Education Systems and Bilingual Initiatives in Belize

Language plays a crucial role in Belize’s educational framework, with bilingual education actively supported. As you explore this dimension, you will find that schools prioritize instruction in both English and Spanish, enabling students to develop comprehensive communication skills. This dual-language approach ensures that students appreciate diverse cultural perspectives, preparing them for varied professional opportunities in an increasingly interconnected global landscape that values linguistic diversity.

Examine Government Communication Practices and Their Use of English

Official government communications are primarily conducted in English, enhancing administrative efficiency. You will observe that official documents, legislative processes, and public announcements are regularly published in English, reflecting the enduring legacy of British administrative practices in the nation. This reliance on English facilitates clear communication, ensuring that governance remains accessible to the populace.

Gaining insight into Belize’s governmental language practices reveals a sophisticated communication strategy. You will find that while English remains the primary administrative language, there is a growing recognition of the importance of multilingual communication within government institutions. Official translations and multicultural outreach initiatives signify a commitment to inclusive governance that respects the country’s linguistic diversity, fostering unity among its varied populations.

Appreciate the Economic Value of English in the Tourism Sector

In the wake of British colonial influence, English has evolved into a strategic economic asset. You will recognize how this linguistic advantage appeals to international visitors and investors, positioning Belize as a welcoming destination for English-speaking tourists and businesses seeking opportunities in the region. This advantage enhances the country’s attractiveness as a premier tourist locale, stimulating economic growth through tourism.

The presence of multilingualism is reshaping Belize’s economic framework, creating competitive advantages in global markets. You will witness how effective communication in English facilitates international trade, tourism expansion, and cross-cultural business interactions. This linguistic flexibility positions Belize as an appealing destination for foreign investment and cultural exchanges, further integrating it into the global economy.

Understand the Lasting Legacy of British Influence on Language

Despite its geographical proximity to Spanish-speaking nations, Belize’s linguistic heritage is a direct result of British colonial governance. You will discover that the English language became deeply embedded during the era of British Honduras, establishing a unique linguistic environment that distinguishes Belize from its Central American counterparts. This legacy continues to shape Belizean culture, identity, and communication practices today.

Forge a Strong Cultural Identity and National Pride Through Language

Before attaining independence in 1981, Belizeans developed a multifaceted cultural identity that blended British administrative traditions with local indigenous and Caribbean influences. This rich multicultural heritage transformed English from a mere colonial language into a symbol of national unity and pride, reflecting the nation’s diverse cultural tapestry. The adoption of English has enabled Belizeans to connect with the global community while preserving their unique cultural identity.

Maintain Ongoing Connections to the British Monarchy and Its Influence

Belize maintains a fascinating constitutional link to the British Crown, operating as a Commonwealth realm. You will note that historically, Queen Elizabeth II served as the head of state, with a Governor-General representing her interests in Belize. This relationship highlights the continuous influence of British governance on Belizean society.

The intertwining of cultures persists in Belize’s ongoing relationship with the British monarchy. While the King of the United Kingdom remains the official head of state, day-to-day governance is administered by Belizean elected officials. This unique arrangement symbolizes the enduring diplomatic and historical ties between Belize and the United Kingdom, reflecting a blend of governance practices.

Explore Belize’s Political Framework: Governance Structure

In 1981, Belize transitioned to a parliamentary democracy modeled after the British Westminster system. You will find that this political structure guarantees democratic representation while preserving symbolic connections to British governmental traditions. This system reflects the lasting impact of British administrative practices that have significantly influenced Belize’s governance since colonial times.

Investigate Sociolinguistic Research in Belize

A considerable number of sociolinguistic researchers have examined the intricate language dynamics of Belize, focusing on how English intertwines with Creole, Spanish, and Indigenous languages. You will find that the linguistic landscape serves as a reflection of the country’s unique multicultural heritage. Academic inquiries highlight how language functions as a vital marker of national identity, tracing the complex social interactions that shape communication across diverse communities.

Analyze Language Attitudes and Their Social Implications

Research on language attitudes in Belize illustrates how English functions as a symbol of social mobility. You may be surprised to learn that perceptions of language can significantly influence social opportunities. Linguistic studies indicate that proficiency in English often correlates with educational and professional advancement, creating a complex social hierarchy that impacts interpersonal relationships and economic opportunities within Belizean society.

Document Linguistic Diversity Through Thorough Research

Academic research in Belize has meticulously cataloged the remarkable linguistic diversity present within the nation. You will discover that scholars have systematically mapped language variations across regions, capturing the nuanced ways communities communicate and engage. These documentation efforts serve to preserve the rich linguistic tapestry that characterizes Belize’s unique communication patterns, ensuring that the voices of diverse populations are recognized and valued.

Given the depth of linguistic research, you’ll find that thorough documentation plays a critical role in understanding Belize’s language ecosystem. Researchers have conducted extensive fieldwork to gather data on language usage, document endangered languages, and analyze the intricate interactions between English, Creole, Spanish, and Indigenous languages. Your comprehension of Belize’s linguistic landscape will be enriched by these systematic scholarly investigations, revealing how language reflects historical, social, and cultural transformations in the region.

Explore Language Representation in Popular Culture

Your examination of Belize’s linguistic landscape uncovers how English permeates daily life, illustrating the country’s multifaceted historical narrative. The language serves not only as a communication tool but also as a cultural identifier connecting various ethnic backgrounds, uniting Belizeans through a shared linguistic heritage rooted in British colonial history.

Discover Music and the Arts as Mediums of Cultural Expression

Through the creative application of English, Belizean artists transform language into a vibrant medium for cultural storytelling. Musical genres such as punta rock and traditional Creole performances exemplify how English intertwines with local rhythms, enabling artists to express the nuanced experiences of identity, struggle, and celebration that resonate deeply within the Belizean community.

Assess the Role of Media in Shaping Language Perception

Within Belize’s media landscape lies a robust linguistic ecosystem where English prevails across television, radio, and digital platforms. Local news outlets and radio stations primarily broadcast in English, reinforcing its status as the principal communication channel and national language. This media landscape plays a critical role in shaping public perception and maintaining the relevance of English in everyday discourse.

Culture significantly influences media’s linguistic role, with broadcasting networks strategically utilizing English to reach diverse audiences. Approximately 63% of Belizean media content is produced in English, underscoring its considerable impact on language perception and national communication strategies. Your understanding of this dynamic illustrates how media functions as a crucial mechanism for language preservation, ensuring the continued relevance of English in contemporary Belizean society while celebrating the country’s rich cultural tapestry.

Confront the Challenges of Language Preservation in Belize

Despite the rich variety of linguistic diversity, Belize faces substantial challenges in preserving its unique linguistic heritage. You will find that while English retains its status as the official language, the nation’s linguistic landscape is increasingly threatened by gradual language erosion and shifting social dynamics that challenge traditional communication patterns. The pressures of modernization and globalization present both opportunities and challenges for language preservation initiatives.

Identify the Threats Facing Local Languages and Cultural Heritage

At the intersection of globalization and cultural change, indigenous languages such as Kriol, Garifuna, and Maya face unprecedented challenges. You can observe how younger generations are increasingly opting for English, potentially leading to a dramatic decline in linguistic heritage within just one or two generations. This trend raises critical concerns about the future of Belize’s linguistic diversity and cultural richness.

Implement Strategies for Language Maintenance and Revitalization

Preserving Belize’s linguistic diversity requires comprehensive and multifaceted strategies. You will discover that educational initiatives, community engagement, and cultural documentation play essential roles in protecting linguistic diversity. Local schools are adopting bilingual curricula to ensure that younger generations remain connected to their linguistic roots, fostering an appreciation for all languages spoken in Belize.

Addressing the threats to linguistic diversity necessitates proactive measures. Recognizing that preserving languages calls for more than mere academic documentation, it necessitates active community involvement. Collaborative efforts between government bodies, educational institutions, and indigenous communities can promote sustainable language revitalization programs. Furthermore, digital platforms, multimedia resources, and intergenerational knowledge transfer are increasingly vital in preserving Belize’s linguistic richness and ensuring that future generations are equipped to celebrate their diverse heritage.

Conduct a Comparative Linguistic Analysis of Belize’s Language Environment

To appreciate the complexity of Belize’s linguistic environment, you will encounter a nuanced comparison between its language patterns and regional variations. The following table illustrates key linguistic characteristics that highlight the unique aspects of Belize’s multilingual society:

Language Characteristic Belize Specifics
Primary Language English (Official)
Secondary Languages Spanish, Kriol, Garifuna

Contextualize English Within the Caribbean Language Framework

A significant aspect of Belize’s linguistic heritage is its alignment with Caribbean English variants. You will observe that British colonial influence has profoundly shaped language development, resulting in distinctive communication patterns shared across former British territories. This connection emphasizes the broader impact of colonial histories on contemporary linguistic practices.

Uncover Belize’s Unique Linguistic Landscape and Cultural Narrative

History reveals that the evolution of language in Belize is a product of complex colonial interactions. You’ll discover a vibrant multilingual environment where English coexists with indigenous and immigrant languages, reflecting the country’s rich cultural diversity. This context demonstrates that Belize’s linguistic diversity is more than a historical artifact; it serves as a powerful narrative of survival, adaptation, and cultural resilience.

You will appreciate how English serves as a unifying medium while simultaneously preserving unique cultural identities, with approximately 62.9% of the population communicating in English as either a primary or secondary language. This linguistic landscape fosters a sense of belonging among Belizeans while accentuating the importance of maintaining their diverse heritage.

Examine International Influences Shaping Belize’s Linguistic Landscape

International dynamics have not only molded Belize’s linguistic environment but have also profoundly influenced its cultural and economic development. The British colonial legacy intertwines with ongoing global relationships, crafting a unique national identity that transcends traditional boundaries. Your exploration of Belize’s linguistic evolution reveals a complex narrative of power, migration, and cultural exchange that continues to unfold in contemporary society.

Assess Globalization and Its Impact on Linguistic Dynamics

By embracing global communication networks, Belize has positioned itself as a multilingual hub where English serves as a strategic advantage. Your investigation of linguistic dynamics uncovers how international trade, tourism, and educational exchanges have solidified English’s role as a primary communication tool, allowing Belizeans to effectively engage in global conversations while promoting their local culture.

Recognize the Impact of Diaspora Communities on Language Usage

In any discussion regarding Belize’s linguistic identity, it’s vital to acknowledge the significant influence of diaspora communities. Migrant networks have consistently reinforced English language practices, establishing transnational connections that sustain cultural and linguistic continuity across borders. This influence has enriched Belize’s social fabric while promoting a diverse linguistic environment.

The transformation of Belize’s societal landscape is largely due to trade networks and migration patterns. Diaspora communities residing in the United States, United Kingdom, and Canada have maintained strong ties to their homeland, facilitating remittances, sharing cultural knowledge, and preserving linguistic traditions. Your understanding of these dynamics highlights how approximately 15% of Belize’s population lives abroad, creating vital channels of cultural and linguistic exchange that continually reshape national identity and communication practices.

Project the Future of Language in Belize

It’s crucial to acknowledge that Belize’s linguistic landscape continues to evolve, blending historical influences with contemporary dynamics. Although English remains the official language, the nation’s multilingual identity promises an exciting and diverse future. You will find that Belize’s commitment to linguistic diversity reflects its rich cultural heritage, with Creole, Spanish, and indigenous languages playing vital roles in shaping communication patterns and cultural interactions.

Anticipate Emerging Linguistic Trends and Developments in Belize

Amid the forces of globalization and local cultural preservation, you can expect Belize’s language ecosystem to grow increasingly complex. Younger generations are likely to become more multilingual, exhibiting heightened proficiency in Spanish and indigenous languages alongside English. The interplay of educational policies and economic opportunities will continue to shape these linguistic transformations, potentially resulting in a more nuanced communication landscape that mirrors the diverse identities of its people.

Recognize the Importance of Language Policy and Strategic Planning

Language policy is vital in shaping Belize’s linguistic future, with governmental strategies and educational initiatives taking precedence. Protecting linguistic diversity is crucial for policymakers who understand the necessity of maintaining cultural identities while promoting effective communication. Acknowledging the significance of all languages will cultivate a more inclusive society.

Moreover, comprehensive planning is essential to balance preservation and progress. Educational institutions play a vital role in developing multilingual curricula that honor Belize’s diverse linguistic heritage. You will find that strategic language planning can help uphold English as a unifying language while simultaneously fostering the growth of other languages within the country, ensuring that all voices are acknowledged and respected.

Explore Case Studies Highlighting Language Use Trends in Belize

Belize’s linguistic landscape showcases intriguing patterns of language integration. The following case studies illuminate the complex dynamics of English usage across various societal contexts:

  • Urban centers such as Belize City: 98% English proficiency
  • Rural Mayan communities: 65% bilingual rates
  • Coastal regions: High prevalence of Creole language
  • Professional sectors: 85% English-dominant communication
  • Educational institutions: Mandatory English instruction

Explore the Distinct Language Dynamics of Rural and Urban Belize

Before examining linguistic variations, it’s essential to recognize that rural and urban settings display unique communication patterns. Rural areas tend to maintain stronger connections to indigenous languages, whereas urban centers show a more standardized use of English, creating a nuanced linguistic ecosystem that reflects Belize’s complex historical heritage and its ongoing evolution.

Understand the Effects of Multilingual Families on Children’s Language Development

Within Belizean families, multilingual transmission represents a dynamic cultural phenomenon. Children often navigate between English, Spanish, Kriol, and indigenous languages, cultivating remarkable linguistic flexibility from a young age. This early exposure to multiple languages fosters an inclusive and adaptable mindset.

Further investigation reveals that bilingual families confer significant cognitive advantages to children. Neurological research suggests that multilingual exposure enhances cognitive processing, nurturing adaptive communication skills that transcend conventional linguistic boundaries. You will find that these children demonstrate improved problem-solving abilities and cultural adaptability, positioning them as unique linguistic ambassadors in an interconnected global landscape that values diversity.

Recognize the Contributions of Key Figures in Language Advocacy

For decades, advocates for language preservation in Belize have played a crucial role in maintaining and promoting English as a national communication tool. You will discover that these individuals have been instrumental in shaping the linguistic landscape, ensuring that English remains a unifying force among diverse ethnic groups. Their advocacy has transformed language from a colonial remnant into a powerful instrument of national identity, fostering a sense of belonging among Belizeans.

Appreciate the Impact of Activists and Linguists on Language Preservation

Linguistic experts and social advocates in Belize have been vital in understanding and promoting the dynamics of language. You will find that their meticulous documentation of the evolution of English illustrates its significance beyond colonial narratives. Their research highlights how language preservation contributes to cultural resilience and national unity, making English a powerful symbol of Belizean social cohesion and identity.

Examine the Role of Government Policymakers in Language Dynamics

Government officials in Belize have strategically established English as the official language, recognizing its potential to enhance international communication and stimulate economic growth. You will see how their policies have systematically embedded English in education, governance, and public services, ensuring broad linguistic accessibility and opportunities for all Belizeans.

Linguists and policymakers have collaborated to devise comprehensive language strategies. You will appreciate their development of educational frameworks that protect linguistic diversity while ensuring that English remains the primary medium of instruction. Their approach acknowledges that language policy transcends mere communication; it is about national identity formation. By investing in bilingual and multilingual education programs, they have ensured that Belize’s linguistic landscape remains dynamic and inclusive, celebrating all voices within its vibrant community.

Reflect on the Key Lessons from Belize’s Linguistic Journey

Belize’s linguistic landscape is a reflection of its intricate colonial history. As you traverse the country’s past, you will discover that British colonial rule profoundly influenced its language and cultural identity. The era of British Honduras established English as the official language, which continues to define Belize’s national communication today. Your understanding of this historical journey reveals how colonial legacies persist, with English serving as a unifying force among Belize’s diverse ethnic groups. When considering the nation’s unique trajectory, you will come to realize that language is more than just a means of communication—it is a testament to Belize’s resilient national spirit and its capacity to transform historical challenges into a distinctive cultural narrative that enriches the Belizean experience.

Find Answers to Common Questions About Belize’s Language Dynamics

What factors contribute to Belize’s primary use of English despite its geographical location in Central America?

The primary use of English in Belize can be traced to its historical context as a British colony, known as British Honduras, from 1862 until 1981. The British established administrative and educational systems that entrenched English as the official language, creating a linguistic legacy that persists in modern Belizean society.

How did British colonial governance shape language development in Belize?

British colonial administrators mandated English as the language of government, education, and commerce. They implemented educational policies requiring English instruction, effectively establishing it as the primary communication medium across both administrative and social domains. This decision has had lasting effects on Belize’s linguistic landscape.

What linguistic diversity exists alongside English in Belize?

While English is the official language, Belize features a rich linguistic landscape that includes Kriol (an English-based creole), Spanish, Garifuna, Maya languages, and Mandarin. This multilingual environment reflects the country’s diverse ethnic composition and complex historical interactions, enriching the cultural fabric of Belizean society.

When did Belize achieve independence, and how did this affect its language status?

Belize gained independence from the United Kingdom on September 21, 1981. Despite achieving political independence, the country retained English as its official language, underscoring the enduring linguistic influence of British colonial governance and the foundational role of English in national identity.

How does language today reflect Belize’s national identity?

English embodies Belize’s historical ties to British colonial heritage while simultaneously representing its modern capabilities for international communication. The language serves as a unifying element among Belize’s diverse ethnic groups, facilitating global economic and diplomatic interactions, and reinforcing a collective national identity.

The Article Why Does Belize Speak English? Tracing Its Colonial Roots and Modern Identity appeared first on Belize Travel Guide

The Article Belize’s English: Exploring Colonial Roots and Modern Identity Was Found On https://limitsofstrategy.com

References:

https://limitsofstrategy.com/belizes-english-exploring-colonial-roots-and-modern-identity/

Leave a Comment

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *